Click here to read this article on Academia.edu

Introduction

Malaysia’s transformation into a global semiconductor powerhouse is revolutionising its economic landscape. Once reliant on tin mining and agriculture, the country has successfully diversified its economy, embracing high-tech industries with a strategic vision. This commitment to innovation has positioned Malaysia as a key player in the global supply chain, and now ranks eighth in the world in semiconductor fabrication plants, just behind the United Kingdom. This impressive rise not only underscores Malaysia’s growing influence on the world stage but also marks the beginning of what could be an even greater global impact in the technology sector.

Major technology corporations are increasingly expanding their operations within Malaysia. Companies like Intel and Infineon are investing $7 billion and $8 billion respectively, Nvidia is constructing a $4.3 billion AI data centre, and Texas Instruments is dedicating $3.1 billion towards new semiconductor assembly facilities. Yet, these substantial investments are just the tip of the iceberg. Prominent international companies, including Germany’s Bosch, Austria’s AT&S, Sweden’s Ericsson, South Korea’s Simmtech, and state-backed Chinese manufacturers like Fengshi Metal Technology, are also contributing to this economic surge. The Malaysian government is seizing this momentum, aiming to propel the nation up the global value chain and transform it into a high-tech economy on par with Japan, Taiwan, and South Korea.

But the road to achieving this ambitious goal is not without its challenges. Malaysia must navigate a complex array of obstacles, including those of its own making, as well as external factors like its geopolitical positioning amidst ongoing trade tensions between the United States and China. The stakes are high: the Malaysian government needs to secure at least $107 billion in investments to establish the country as the next global semiconductor hub. Failure to do so could leave Malaysia vulnerable to regional and global economic shifts. As the nation stands at this critical juncture, it must either go big or risk being left behind.

From Circuits to Success: How Malaysia Sparked a Semiconductor Revolution

Malaysia’s semiconductor industry began to take shape in the 1970s when the country first ventured into electronics manufacturing. The government, seeing the potential for growth in this sector, actively encouraged multinational corporations to set up operations in Malaysia. They offered an array of incentives, including a business-friendly environment, low labour costs, and government support. As a result, several semiconductor giants, such as Broadcom, Intel, Western Digital, and Infineon Technologies, established assembly and testing facilities in the country. These early investments played a pivotal role in laying the foundation for Malaysia’s semiconductor industry. When foreign companies entered the market, they not only brought capital but also shared valuable expertise, allowing Malaysian workers to develop specialised skills in semiconductor manufacturing. As a result, the knowledge transfer fuelled the growth of a thriving ecosystem, which remains strong and continues to expand today.

According to the latest reports, Malaysia holds a 13% share of the global market in semiconductor assembly, testing, and packaging. This sector accounts for 25% of the country’s GDP, making Malaysia the world’s sixth-largest exporter of semiconductors. The arrival of major industry leaders had a catalytic effect on the nation. It not only created jobs for Malaysians but also spurred the growth of supporting industries. Local companies emerged to provide essential services like component supply and equipment maintenance, further strengthening Malaysia’s semiconductor ecosystem.

Chips and Talent: How Innovation Fuels Malaysia’s Semiconductor Surge

The remarkable growth of Malaysia’s semiconductor industry is largely due to its focus on nurturing innovation and development. A key factor in this success has been the availability of a skilled and adaptable workforce. Malaysia has invested heavily in education and training programmes specifically designed for the electronics sector. As a result, the country has developed a steady supply of qualified engineers, technicians, and operators who can meet the industry’s demand for skilled labour.

In addition to having a skilled workforce, Malaysia has created a business-friendly environment that promotes innovation and investment. The government has introduced policies to attract foreign direct investment and encourage technology transfer. Combined with Malaysia’s strategic location in Southeast Asia, these efforts have made the country an appealing destination for semiconductor companies.

Malaysia’s commitment to research and development has played a crucial role in its success. The country is home to several world-class universities and research institutions specialising in microelectronics and related fields. This focus on research and development has allowed Malaysia to move beyond basic assembly and testing and venture into higher-value activities like chip design and development. But the demand for skilled workers is so high that even these efforts are not enough. In the long term, Malaysia will likely need to attract foreign skilled workers to meet the growing demands of its expanding semiconductor industry.

Pandemic Pressure: How Malaysia’s Semiconductor Industry Bounced Back Stronger

The COVID-19 pandemic caused significant disruptions to global supply chains, with the semiconductor industry being particularly affected. Lockdowns and transportation issues led to production delays and shortages of essential components. These challenges exposed the weaknesses in interconnected supply chains and emphasised the need for greater resilience. Malaysia, a major hub for semiconductor manufacturing, was hit especially hard. Factory closures and movement restrictions affected production schedules, while the increased demand for electronics due to remote work and online learning added further pressure on the industry. The pandemic underscored the importance of diversifying and localising supply chains. As a result, companies began seeking alternative sourcing options and strategies to reduce their reliance on single suppliers or specific regions.

In response to the challenges brought on by the pandemic, Malaysia has taken important steps to strengthen its semiconductor industry and make it more resilient. One major focus has been on diversifying where and how semiconductors are made. To do this, the government has introduced policies that encourage companies to find multiple sources for their materials and reduce their dependence on a single supplier.

The Malaysian government has also worked to foster greater collaboration within the industry. By facilitating partnerships between local and multinational companies, they have promoted knowledge sharing, technology transfer, and joint ventures. These efforts aim to make the Malaysian semiconductor industry more competitive on a global scale.

Malaysia also understands the need to invest in advanced technologies to climb higher in the value chain. This means focusing on areas like chip design, advanced packaging, and developing the next generation of semiconductor materials. By doing so, Malaysia hopes to secure its position as a key player in the global semiconductor market.

Vision 2020: The Government Blueprint Behind Malaysia’s High-Tech Transformation

Malaysia’s economic transformation was meticulously planned. In 1991, Mahathir Mohamad unveiled Vision 2020, an ambitious plan designed to elevate the country to developed nation status by the year 2020. This vision identified nine strategic challenges, such as achieving economic prosperity and advancing technology. To turn this vision into reality, the Malaysian government introduced a series of five-year development plans. Each plan set specific targets in sectors like manufacturing, education, and technology. These consecutive plans guided investments, policy reforms, and human capital development, laying the foundation for Malaysia’s current industrial ambitions.

The Malaysian government played a crucial role in supporting the growth of the semiconductor industry, recognising its importance for the country’s future. To help the industry thrive, the government has introduced policies and incentives aimed at attracting investments, encouraging innovation, and boosting competitiveness.

One important step the government has taken is creating specialised industrial zones, like the Bayan Lepas Free Industrial Zone in Penang. These zones offer a range of benefits to semiconductor companies, such as tax breaks, simplified regulations, and access to state-of-the-art infrastructure. These incentives have played a big role in attracting multinational corporations to set up operations in Malaysia.

Beyond the financial perks, the government has worked hard to create a business-friendly environment. This includes investing in reliable power supplies, high-speed internet, and efficient logistics networks. These efforts ensure that companies have everything they need to succeed and grow in Malaysia.

Chip Nation: Malaysia’s Rise as a Global Semiconductor Leader

These government initiatives have significantly reduced operating costs for businesses, making Malaysia’s semiconductor industry more competitive. With global giants and a vibrant ecosystem of local companies, this sector is rapidly becoming a cornerstone of the nation’s economy.

In December 2021, American chip giant Intel announced a $7 billion investment to build a chip packaging and testing factory in Malaysia, with production set to begin in 2024. This move is part of a larger trend where multinational companies, like AMD, are setting up major manufacturing operations in the country. Attracted by lower operational costs and driven by US-China tensions, these companies are diversifying their production by expanding into Malaysia. The influx of industry leaders has not only increased direct foreign investment but also brought in advanced technology and cultivated local expertise. Their presence has created a ripple effect, spurring the growth of supporting industries and creating a thriving ecosystem of suppliers, service providers, and specialised talent.

Further inland, in the Kulim district, Germany’s Infineon is making a substantial $5.4 billion investment to build the world’s largest production facility for silicon carbide chips, a critical component for electric vehicles. At the same time, over 50 Chinese conglomerates are strategically relocating their operations southward to avoid Washington’s sanctions on Chinese manufacturing. Despite these geopolitical tensions, private logistics giants like DHL Express are stepping in to establish essential supply chains. These links connect southern China’s industrial hubs with Malaysia’s Penang, ensuring seamless integration into the global manufacturing network.

In tandem with these multinational giants, Malaysia also boasts a number of homegrown semiconductor companies that have emerged as pivotal players in the global supply chain. These companies have carved out niches in areas such as outsourced assembly and testing, radio frequency components, and optoelectronics. The port cities of Klang and Tanjung Pelepas, already ranked among the 15 largest ports in the world by capacity, are on the cusp of significant transformation. The government has designated these locations for development into major industrial hubs, where semiconductor chips will be manufactured, rigorously tested, and distributed to consumers worldwide.

Beyond these port cities, in the neighbouring regions of Seremban and Malacca, the government is actively working to attract semiconductor giants like Nexperia and Infineon, positioning these areas as critical centres of high-tech innovation. Meanwhile, across the sea in Borneo, the city of Kuching is experiencing remarkable growth, with Japanese firms such as Taiyo Yuden expanding their operations.

As this hive of high-tech activity steadily spreads across the nation, it becomes clear that Malaysia is on the brink of even greater advancements. The future holds immense promise, with the nation poised to solidify its position at the forefront of the global semiconductor industry.

Breaking the Middle-Income Trap

Malaysia, known for its rich biodiversity and stunning landscapes, has long sought to shift from low-end manufacturing to high-value industries. Like South Korea, Malaysia has struggled to grow its economy. Both nations began their industrialisation efforts in the 1960s with similar GDP per capita levels. While economic growth followed, wages in Malaysia rose too rapidly, diminishing the competitiveness of its industries that was reliant on cheap labour. This phenomenon, known as the middle-income trap, has kept Malaysia in a position where it is neither truly wealthy nor entirely impoverished.

In contrast, South Korea managed to break free from the middle-income trap by 1985 through substantial investments in innovation and productivity, which propelled its GDP per capita to high-income status. Malaysia, however, was unable to develop innovative industries in time, leaving it mired in the trap.

Today, Malaysia is determined to correct its course. Amidst rising tensions between Beijing and Washington, technology giants are adopting a China Plus One strategy, diversifying their operations into other economies to enhance profits and security. Malaysia is well-positioned within the rapidly growing $617 billion global semiconductor industry, thanks to its strategic location, strong infrastructure, established semiconductor sector, and educated, English-speaking workforce. These advantages give Malaysia a competitive edge in the race for dominance in artificial intelligence, advanced robotics, and green technology development.

To raise Malaysia’s status as “the next Taiwan,” local companies like SilTerra and Oppstar Technology are capitalising on the influx of foreign expertise. Their goal is to expand into high-end activities such as wafer fabrication and integrated circuit design. Supporting this ambitious vision, the Malaysian government has unveiled the New Industrial Masterplan 2030 (NIMP 2030)—a comprehensive set of policies designed to boost domestic production and establish Malaysia as the next global hub for semiconductor manufacturing.

Penang’s Second Act: Reviving Malaysia’s Silicon Valley Dream

Despite its ambitious goals, Malaysia’s pursuit of becoming a global semiconductor powerhouse is not without significant risks. Large-scale industrial projects have had a mixed history of success in the country. In the 1970s, Malaysia embarked on a radical economic restructuring effort under the New Economic Policy (NEP), which aimed to redistribute wealth within the country while shifting the economy away from the export of raw materials like rubber and tin.

In the post-colonial era, Malaysia embarked on a journey to redefine its national identity and tackle the deep-rooted ethnic inequalities that had caused major unrest, such as the 1964 expulsion of ethnic Chinese from Singapore. In response, the government introduced reforms that sparked industrial growth and gave rise to a thriving semiconductor industry.

Despite these positive strides, Malaysia remained dependent on low-cost manufacturing, which slowed its progress toward becoming a high-income economy. To fast-track this transition, the government poured resources into developing high-tech industries.

However, one crucial oversight stood in the way: a lack of focus on research and development. This has severely limited Malaysia’s ability to innovate and compete globally. Without prioritising research and development, the country risks stalling its technological growth and falling short of its goal to diversify the economy and become a leader in high-value industries.

Malaysia had an ace up its sleeve in its post-colonial strategy: a bold 50-year plan to turn the coastal state of Penang into the “Silicon Valley of the East.” Once a small fishing village, Penang had played a key role as a British naval base in the 19th century. After independence, however, its strategic location became a geoeconomic asset. The Bayan Lepas Free Industrial Zone has attracted major global players like Bosch, Motorola, Dell, Intel, and Hewlett-Packard, transforming Penang into a hub for high-tech innovation.

By the 1990s, Penang had completely reinvented itself, going from a quiet post-colonial territory to one of Malaysia’s biggest success stories. Today, Penang is home to over 350 multinational companies and plays a key role in the global economy, producing about 5% of the world’s semiconductor exports. Despite its small size, Penang punches above its weight, contributing nearly 8% to Malaysia’s entire economic output.

However, Penang’s rapid success also became its downfall. Lawmakers in Malaysia’s capital, Kuala Lumpur, felt overshadowed by Penang’s growth. In an effort to boost Kuala Lumpur’s status, they began redirecting resources, talent, and investment away from Penang and other provinces to the capital. Unfortunately, this shift caused Penang to lose some of its prominence. Major global companies like South Korea’s Samsung and Taiwan’s TSMC began sidelining Malaysia’s local manufacturing efforts, further contributing to Penang’s push to the sidelines.

As of 2024, Malaysia is seizing its second chance to achieve lasting economic prosperity. This time, the government is taking a more thoughtful and strategic approach by investing heavily in the nation’s industrial sector. A key focus of this plan is revitalising Penang as an important industrial hub. A new, state-of-the-art, one-million-square-foot industrial park is currently under construction in Penang, drawing interest from major global players such as Jabil, Western Digital, and Lam Research. This ambitious development marks an exciting new chapter in Malaysia’s industrial growth, positioning the country as a rising powerhouse for global innovation and investment.

Navigating Brain Drain, Rivalries, and Geopolitical Challenges

Southeast Asia is in the midst of an economic boom, with many major tech companies offshoring their operations away from China. This shift has made the ASEAN region a prime destination for high-tech industries seeking expansion. Countries like Singapore, Thailand, and Vietnam are emerging as strong competitors to Malaysia, particularly in the fast-growing semiconductor sector. However, Malaysia faces significant challenges, leading some companies to think twice about investing there.

Malaysia’s wealth redistribution policies have also unexpectedly triggered a brain drain, with thousands of non-ethnic Malays leaving the country—many of whom haven’t returned. By the 1980s, Malaysia’s economic growth had slowed significantly, and the Asian financial crisis of 1997 only made things worse. This downturn has kept Malaysia stuck in the middle-income trap, making it harder to achieve its long-term economic goals.

Today, the country faces a labour shortage of around 1.2 million workers, especially in the engineering and manufacturing sectors. One of the biggest concerns is the lack of skilled engineers, with only 5,000 graduating each year. To tackle this, the government plans to train 60,000 semiconductor engineers, but this initiative will falter if wages don’t improve. Right now, Malaysian engineers earn just 90% of the median national wage, a gap that keeps pushing talent abroad and threatens the country’s ambitions in the high-tech industry.

Another pressing domestic issue is the rising cost of housing, particularly in Penang. As more foreign companies set up operations there, property prices have soared. While local authorities have implemented rent controls, these measures provide only temporary relief. In Malaysia’s federal system, regional issues like these can quickly escalate into broader socio-economic concerns, potentially creating difficulties for the ruling coalition. Addressing the housing crisis requires a delicate balance between local governance and federal policy. A long-term, sustainable strategy is needed to ensure housing remains affordable, both in Penang and across Malaysia.

Meanwhile, neighbouring Singapore has attracted $4 billion in investments from industry giants like Global Foundries and Vanguard International Semiconductor, a subsidiary of TSMC. Adding to this momentum, Applied Materials is solidifying its presence in the city-state with a $450 million manufacturing facility. Singapore’s close proximity to Malaysia, combined with its significantly higher wages, averaging $1,495 per month compared to Malaysia’s $469 per month, make it an exceptionally attractive destination for skilled Malaysian professionals. This economic disparity has fuelled a notable rise in emigration, with the number of Malaysians relocating to Singapore surging by 62% in the first quarter of 2024 compared to the same period last year.

Singapore’s advantage is further strengthened by its stable system of governance. In contrast, Malaysia has seen four different prime ministers in just four years, with rapid leadership changes often fuelled by political scandals. This instability undermines cohesive policymaking and creates an unfavourable environment for multinational corporations looking to establish long-term operations. For example, the ongoing debate over the goods and services tax (GST) illustrates this inconsistency. First introduced by Prime Minister Najib Razak in April 2015, the tax was repealed by Mahathir Mohamad in May 2018. Now, current Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim is pushing for its reintroduction, highlighting the kind of legislative back-and-forth that deters investment.

*As of September 2024, Anwar Ibrahim is the 10th and incumbent Prime Minister of Malaysia.

Singapore’s political and administrative stability makes it a far more reliable destination for multinational corporations seeking a robust regulatory system. But Singapore isn’t Malaysia’s only competition. Thailand, for example, presents a compelling alternative, with its well-developed infrastructure, highly skilled workforce, geopolitical neutrality, and generous tax incentives. It’s no wonder major corporations like Sony Group have taken notice.

Similarly, Vietnam has become a rising star in the region, drawing significant attention from global tech players. Samsung, for instance, has invested $3.3 billion to boost its semiconductor production in Vietnam. The country’s strategic location near China’s southern industrial zones, along with its stable political and demographic environment, further strengthens its appeal. Like Malaysia, Vietnam is positioning itself as a strong contender in the global semiconductor race, challenging established players in the pursuit of becoming the next leader in chip manufacturing.

Despite these challenges, Malaysia still has strategic options. Its proximity to competitors like Singapore presents an opportunity for collaboration rather than rivalry. Instead of positioning itself as a direct competitor, Malaysia could explore cooperative strategies with Singapore, allowing both nations to work in tandem and leverage each other’s strengths. For instance, Malaysian firms could specialise in assembling, testing, and packaging semiconductors that are designed and manufactured in Singapore. However, achieving this industrial synergy would require Malaysia to recalibrate its ambitions of becoming a dominant global semiconductor player. In practical terms, this shift may involve prioritising collaboration over competition, potentially sidelining struggling local firms like UNISEM, Carsem, and Inari Amertron, as Malaysia adopts a more complementary role in the sector.

Nonetheless, this strategy could preserve Malaysia’s regional dominance. However, Malaysia must proceed with caution. While businesses are driven by profits, geopolitics sets the rules. The United States has already expressed concerns over Prime Minister Anwar Ibrahim’s cooperation with Chinese firms, sparking fears that sanctions may be extended to include Malaysia. For example, Jetronic Automation, a Malaysian firm, has faced scrutiny for allegedly supplying strategic electronic components to Russia in violation of international sanctions. Should Washington opt to impose punitive measures, it could swiftly and decisively end Malaysia’s booming semiconductor industry with a single stroke.

Moreover, China accounts for $56.7 billion of Malaysia’s imports and $103 billion of its exports, including crucial materials like germanium and gallium, which are essential for semiconductor production. For the last 15 years, China has been Malaysia’s largest trading partner, while the United States remains its top investment partner. This places Malaysia in a precarious position, caught between two global economic giants. To navigate these competing interests, Malaysia must carefully balance its relationships with both nations, avoiding actions that might provoke either side.

Conclusion

Malaysia’s journey towards becoming a global semiconductor giant is one of immense promise, but it is also fraught with significant challenges. The nation has undergone a profound economic transformation, evolving into a robust and highly diversified economy, as evidenced by its impressive 4.2% growth rate in the first quarter of 2024 alone. This transformation has been driven by a strategic vision, strong government support, and a favourable business environment, which have collectively attracted substantial investments in the semiconductor sector.

However, this progress is tempered by internal challenges such as brain drain, political instability, and fierce regional competition, which present formidable obstacles. Furthermore, Malaysia’s delicate position within the geopolitical landscape, caught between the United States and China, further complicates its ambitions. If Malaysia can effectively navigate these risks while continuing to build on its strengths, it stands a strong chance of solidifying its position as a key player in the global semiconductor industry.